Prof. Dr. Ertugrul ERDIN
Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Mühendislik Fakültesi Cevre Mühendisligi Bölümü BUCA
Universitaet Tel : 0090.232. 4531143/1120; 4531008; 4532646; 4531129; Fax: 3887864; 4531150
Privat Tel.: (0090.232) 3751324 (mit Anrufsbeanworter)
Private Adresse: 113/1 Sokak Nr.1/2 Daire 6 Nazlikent / Bornova.IZMIR-TR
E-Mail:
eerdin@izmir.eng.deu.edu.tr oder dmucev01@vm3090.ege.edu.tr
Gastvortrag am 02.07.1998 um 11.00 Uhr im Zeughaus/Seminarraum
Abfalltechnik in der Türkei
1. Populationsdynamik
1.1. Gross-
Staedte wie Ýstanbul, Ýzmir, Ankara, Adana und Bursa etc1.2. Mittlere Staedte wie Denizli, Aydýn, Samsun , Konya, Diyarbakýr und etc
1.3. Kleinere Staedte wie Menemen, Bafra, Uþak, Rize, Isparta und etc
1.4. Laedliche Gebiete, kleinere Siedlungen etc.
1.5. Touristisch gepraegte Gebiete wie Antalya, Marmaris, Bodrum, Fethiye,
Kusadasi und etc. (bzw. touristisch gepraegte Betriebe)
2. Wirtschaftliche Sektoren und deren Abfallproduktion
2.1. Landwirtschaftliche Sektoren
2.2. Forstwirtschaftliche Sektoren
2.3. Dienstleistungen (Tourism als Sektor)
2.4. Industrielle Sektor
2.4.1. Industrielle Sektor mit gefaehrlichen Abfaellen
2.4.2. Industrielle Sektor mit nicht gefaehrlichen Abfaellen
3. Abfallquellen und Mengen
(Staedtische Siedlungsabfaelle und laendliche Siedlungasabfaelle)
3.1. Landwirtschaftliche Abfaelle
3.2. Forstwirtschaftliche Abfaelle
3.3. Touristischen Gebietsabfaelle
3..4. Industrielle Abfaelle
3.4.1. Industrielle gefaehrliche Abfaellen
3..4.2. Industrielle nicht gefaehrliche Abfaellen
4. Abfallerfassung, Behandlung und Endentsorgung
4.1. Abfallsammlung und –Transport
4.2. Abfallbehandlung
4.2.1. Abfallsortierung vor Ort
Prof. Dr. Ertugrul ERDIN
Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Mühendislik Fakültesi Cevre Mühendisligi Bölümü BUCA-Universitaet Tel : 0090.232. 4531143/1120; 4531008; 4532646; 4531129; Fax: 3887864;
Privat Tel.: (0090.232) 3751324 (mit Anrufsbeanworter)
Private Adresse: 113/1 Sokak Nr.1/2 Daire 6 Nazlikent / Bornova.IZMIR-TR
E-Mail:
eerdin@izmir.eng.deu.edu.tr oder dmucev01@vm3090.ege.edu.tr
Abfalltechnik in der Türkei
4.2.2. Abfallsortierung auf der Deponi oder Kompostanlage
4.2.3. Abfallbehandlung
4.2.3.1. Kompostierung
4.2.3.2. Verbrennung
4.2.4. Endentsorgung
4.2.4.1. Ungeordnete Deponien
4.2.4.2. Teilgut geordnete Deponien
4.2.4.3. Gute geordnete Deponien
5. Ausblick
6. Literatur:
The Regulation for Management of Solid Wastes Nr. 20814 dated 14th March 1991 organzes legal aspects of collection, transport and disposal of garbage and solid wastes in Turkey. Definitions are given in Article 3.
Detailed over the laws and regulations;
1) Constitution : Article 56 of Constitution of Republic of Türkiye enacted in 1982 states that, living in a healthy and balanced environment is the right of everybody and developing the environment, protecting the environmental health and prevention of environmental pollution are responsibility of both the Government and citizens.
2) Environmental Law: The purpose of this Law is protection, improvement of the environment owned by all the human beings, providing appropriate usage and protection of the urban and residential lands; prevention of air pollution; protection of plant and animal life and natural and historical wealth of the country and development of life status of current and future generations and determining measures that should be taken at this direction in harmony with economical and social development targets.
3) Noise Control Regulation: This law is prepared depending on Article 14 of Environment Law.
Its purpose is to develop an environment that does not destroy peace and silence, physical and moral health. Parallel to this purpose it covers description of terms related with noise and limits where noise control will be applied.
4) Air Quality Protection Regulation: The purpose of this regulation prepared with respect to Environment Law is, controlling any kind of emissions originating from human activities, in the form of smut, smoke, dust, gas, vapor and aerosol, protecting human beings and their environment from dangers of air pollution, eliminating and preventing desolations and negative effects of air pollution.
5) Water Pollution Control Regulation: This regulation is prepared with respect of Articles 8, 11, 12, 13 of Environment Law and its purpose is protecting and optimal usage of water resource potential of the country, preventing water pollution parallel to economical and social development targets and in this aspect presenting necessary constitutional and technical principles for water pollution control.
6) Water Products Law: This law includes factors about water products protection, production and control and states that water products production is possible only with permit memorandum. Preventions about water products protection, arrangements for development, incitement and preservation are purchased by this Law and regulations and circulates related to this Law. With these legislations seas, lakes, dam reservoirs and rivers containing water products are taken under control.
7) Groundwater Law: Groundwaters are under the control and possession of the Government. Any kind of observation that may be done with these waters and their usage, protection and registration is dependent to this law. Consequently, except hand opened wells for other wells, bores and holes permission should be taken from State Water Works (SWW). As their limits and structural properties are determined, groundwater sites are accepted and declared as “Groundwater operation sites” by the related ministry as a result of the proposal done by SWW.
8) IZSU Wastewater Discharge to Sewerage System Regulation: This regulation is enacted on 29.12.1987 after the decision of ÿZSU Council of Managers on 2.12.1987 and No:87/90, and the decision of general meeting on 29.12.1987 No:10 decision.
This regulation determines the factors, methods and limitations about connection of wastewaters to city sewerage system, in places without sewerage system their transportation with an appropriate vehicle and after being treated their disposal to an appropriate receiving medium and usage and protection of sewerage systems inside ÿzmir Metropolitan Municipality vicinity and water source regions.
9) Solid Waste Control Regulation: The purpose of this regulation is; forbidding any activities like disposal of any kind of waste harmful to the environment directly or indirectly to the receiving media; by taking management of all kinds of consumption materials under a certain decipline, preventing destruction of animal and plant specimens from permanent effects of these pollutants in air, water or soil; and determination, application and development of policies and programs in this direction.
10) Necessary Principles In the Collection and Disposal of Solid Wastes Originating From Hospitals and Similar Health Institutions Regulation: This regulation which is prepared with respect to:
is enacted on 15.3.1990 with the decision 52 of City council, in the limits of ÿzmir Metropolitan Municipality.
This purpose of this regulation is to dispose solid wastes originating from hospitals and similar health institutions without giving harm to the environment and public health and without causing aesthetic problems.
11) Notice About Hospital Wastes:
It is enacted with the notice of Prime ministry undersecretariate on 13.9.1991 No AYD/2011-12268 and began to be applied in all the cities.Since hospital wastes show permanent characters in air, water and soil which destroy ecological balance, they are classified in the hazardous wastes category, limitations related with their production, transportation, depositing and disposal are introduced in this notice till the preparation of regulation for these materials by Government Ministry.
12) Public Hygiene Law: This law which was enacted in 1930 provided various rules about protection of public health. Some subjects which take place in this law are explained separately. 11 th part of this law deals with health protection rules in cities and villages and here rules related with water, sewerage, solid waste, residents, hotels and similar public places are given.
13) Municipality Law: Depending to the 15 th Article of Municipality Law numbered 1550, the factors given below are given about the responsibilities of municipalities:
14) Law No: 3030: The purpose of this law is to arrange legal management situation of municipalities, in a way to provide a planned, efficient and appropriate service. This law includes principles and rules about the establishments, duties and authorities of Metropolitan and county municipalities and their relationships with other local authorities and central authorities.
15) Regulation Related with the Application of Law No: 3030: This regulation is arranged depending to the authority given by the 23 th Article of law about acception of written decree in the form of law sentence of management of metropolitan municipalities on 27.6.1984 No:3030.
This regulation arranges principles given below for metropolitan municipalities:
a) Their management, legal and actual states and administrative and local structures,
b) Duty, authority, right, privilege and exemptions,
c) Their relationships with county municipalities in their duty area in duty, authority, goods, and service aspects,
d) Their contact and relation with central administration and connected institutions.
Also it covers principles and rules that will provide a coordinated, balanced and efficient execution of services in the responsibility of metropolitan municipality.
16) Construction Law:
This law is arranged to construct residential areas and other buildings in these areas appropriate to plan, technique, health and environmental conditions. All the buildings which will be constructed inside or outside the limits of the municipalities are dependent to this law.17) Village Law: 13 th Article of this law includes the paragraphs given below about solid wastes:
Paragraph 7: Cleaning places around the houses and village roads, every resident sweeping the front of his house
Paragraph 8: Always keeping places around fountains, wells and springs clean and preventing leakage of these waters in order not to cause mud formation.
Paragraph 9: Disposing garbage and manure of the village at a far out place and showing every house a different spot at this site.
Paragraph 33: Disposing decayed and smelling fruits and other unhealthy materials out of the village and burying them.
18) National Parks Law: The purpose of this law is arranging principles in choosing, protecting and arranging national parks, natural parks, natural statues and nature protection sites which have national and international values.
19) Cultural and Natural Wealth Protection Law: With this law, protection of movable and unmovable cultural and natural properties, arrangement of operations and activities related with these properties, and duties and responsibilities of real and legal people about these properties are determined.
20) Law About Approval of Written Degree about Employment Place and Working Permits by Changing: The purpose of this law is giving employment place opening and working permits for industrial, agricultural and for any kind of employment places; simplification of procedures.
21) ÿzmir Metropolitan Municipality Unhealhful Establishments Regulation: This regulation is prepared depending to 19 th paragraph of the regulation about Metropolitan Municipalities Management published in official newspaper numbered 18603 on December 12 th 1984 depending to the Law no 3030.
This regulation aims to determine the principles in controlling and permitting unhealthful establishments in order to control public health, to provide optimal usage of urban and residential area lands and natural resources, to prevent water, air and soil pollution, and negative factors like noise, insect fight, and to protect natural resources from pollution.
Unhealthful establishments term represents establishments which gives or may give physical, chemical, microbiological, moral and social harms and which may cause pollution of natural resources.
22) ÿzmir Metropolitan Municipality Police Regulation: This is enacted by the decision no: 10-139/6 of Municipality Council on 15.3.1976.
This regulation is prepared to protect public health and comfort and to accomplish the duties given to the municipalities by Municipality Law No:1580 and with other laws.
Paper and metal collection has been organized as a permenent action. They are used as secondary raw materials.
At the same time environmental effect estimation reports must be prepared. The septic tank of Coastal Region Cities, which is one of the main touristic regions and the works done to solve the sewage and the solid waste problems in this area which native technology takes place too.
Municipalities can not mix hospital, clinic and laboratory wastes, radioactive wastes, storage batteries, normal batteries, medicines and pills with domestic solid wastes.
The government, most authorative organization of the city and municipality have responsibilities for disposing of these materials, separately. They can apply the “deposit method”.
In the border of municipality, the municipalities and out of the border, most authorative organization of the city have authority for the following actions:
Producers which produce domestic and industrial wastes which have similar properties with domestic type, must keep own wastes ready for collecting, in a way which is determined by the municipality or most authorative organization of the city.
SOLID WASTES PROBLEM
ÿncreasing population and developing technology are caused different type and amount of solid wastes. Solid waste problem is one of the major environmental problems. There are approximately 2,000 solid waste dumping area in Turkey, which are potential hazard for human health and not meet with the standards.
Municipal solid wastes (Urban Solid Wastes)
ÿn the area of coastal distrikts, the daily production of MSW is lower than 1 kg per capita with an high organic putrescible content. But USW (urban solid wastes ) generation per capita per day is close 1.0 kg. An analysis of MSW related to the tourist area gives: organic 55- 65 %, paper/board 9-12 %, glass 2-3 %, plastics 3-4 %, metals 1- 2 %. The collection of MSW in the center of cities is carried out every day using steel barrels placed on the curbs in front of the buildings; in the poorer quarters other various steel container are used in general recovered from postconsumer wastes.
Amount of per capìta generated dumping solid wastes :
The average composition of municipal solid wastes are rich on food and poor on paper and plastics compared to composition of EC countries solid wastes .
Moisture content is apr. 40 - 50 % and density of SW is 0.30 - 0.35 tons/m3 , a calorific value 6000 - 8000 kJoule/kg SW. The generated average value of solid wastes per capita is about 0.7 kg/day for the and , for the cities about 1.0 kg/day.capita .
Calculation of population projections are made by the taking three sectors : in cities of coastal regions, hilly and mountainouse area.
SW dansity at Landfill (=d) is 0.800 kg/m3
V = Landfillvolume = p.e.c.k/d ; p = size of population, e=the ratio between cover aerth and solid wastes = ¼, and so e= 1,25 , k= days of year = 365, c = kg SW/day.capita
An inspection of the bin content showed the presence of a large amount of organic garbage, some plastic bags and very few cans and plastic bottles, in general these beverage containers are not seen on the ground into the city, only in few cases these products has been seen dispersed on the ground.
It has been referred by some of people met that many recyclable products are recovered before the daily collection directly from the bins on the curbs by abusive organization of collectors. Because of the lack of time no verification has been done, we think that it is very important to contact these collectors in order to define the kind of products recovered, the amount, the prices and the final buyers.
In this landfill some people lives recovering from MSW glass, plastic bottles, cans and other products.
The main idea of the contemporary solid waste management is to reduce the amount of wastes. The best way is to solve the solid waste problem before they occur. For instance, using the recyclable packing material instead of use and waste materials will reduce the amount and the magnitude of environmental pollution. The second main idea is to produce as compost and landfillgas from biode-gredable material.
The Regulation for Management of Solid Wastes Nr. 20814 dated 14th
March 1991 organizes legal basis and aspects of collection, transport, handling, and disposal of garbage and solid wastes in Turkey.
In the 1st and the 2nd paragraphs of “Regulation of Control of Solid Wastes” , following explanations have been stated:
Packaging Regulation and Targets of the Regulation
The details of the applications contained in the said law are the following :
PACKAGING MATERIALS AND 3R
The packkaging classification system adepted like follows :
1. Primary packaging :
This covers packaging for retail to consumers at sale poits the type normlly formingpart of family shopping2. Secondary packaging , this includes packaging designed for containing various items which can be removed without altering package itself . These are mainly discarded from sale by points, but nevertheless also find their way into the domestic environ-ment.
3. Tertiary packaging : tertiary packaging is employed for goods transport and handling to avoid damage.
Shpopping bags should be made from plastic or paper ?
Let us begin with biodegradable plastics ?
3R ( Reuse, Recycling, Recovery )
Selective collection reduces :
The materials which are to be recovered , should be separated by the householders and collected in differnt receptacles by the collection services .
Composting (in the open air - slow composting-, in special enclosures - accelerated composting)
Since 1988 is oparated the composting Facility in Uzundere-Eskiizmir.
ÿt was planned after 1985, at the end of seventhy and plant was finished at 1988. ÿt was costed appr. 10.000.000.000.—Lira.
The contructure firm was a swiss/german/turkish one joint venture.
Explaination of composting process as follows :
Drum and aerated pile process: This process designed patented and developed by the swiss company (Gebrüder Bühler). ÿt is a simple fermentation technique, easy to operate and machinery with a minimum maintenance.
The equipment are of a simple, rustic design, ensuring easy operating with a minimum of manned attention.
Handling capacity is 500 tons per day. Fermentation occurs in longitudinal piles placed side by side in a roofed structure.
After mechanical treatment of solid wastes, are left for 7 days in each parts of piles , which are taken air blown through the bottom. Composting material is turned over every seven days by the paddle-wheel (Combi Star 4000). The blades slice the product from bottom to top and dicharge it. The archimedean screw then projects the aerated, homogenized product into the next piles.
Before mechanical pretreatment, eliminate, separate the recycable materials like glass, plastics, metals, textiles, paper and cardboard, ferrous scrap etc.( 2-4%).
In the marketplace , foreign and domestic manufactures are in competition which makes the domestic companies improve the quality of the products. Achievement of the integration with would be helpful to rise the quality of domestic products. Today, composting technology is crumbling with the hope of running in the future.
RDF - energy recovery (WDF (Waste Derived Fuel)
Nowadays a lot of organic solid wastes are produced in and around the cities and in the forests. In fact, these materials are produced by the transformation of solar energy to chemical energy and have entalphy, to by the use and application of this energy we will be the able to learn the continuously developing technology in this field. In this report will be dealing with the energy production from domestic solid wastes, industrial and commercial solid wastes, the quality of the energy and the methods used for that process the aim is to introduce and give idea about it.
Solid wastes originated from agrìculture, forestry and household, commercial and some industrial can be briquetted and use as fuel Ecofuel or RDF (=refuse derived fuel ) for the home heating or industrial issues. The potential for the using by the cement factory or small house heating is exist. Agricultural and fores-try wastes give the opurtunities to produce it . Therefore they can be recovered over the RDF-processing with differet treatment techniques. The infectiös hospital wastes can be burned in furnaces of cement facilities, and heat energy captured.
Turkey : Arrangement pertaining to garbage and solid waste in Turkey are gathered under primarily the” Environment Act Nr. 2872 effected in 11.08.198, which included certain provisions pertaining to the environment. Article 8 of the said law reads : “ It is forbidden to deliver to receiving media either directly or indirectly or store , transport dispose of or deal in similar ways with all kinds of wastes and garbage in a manner contradicting with standards and methods specified in relevant regulations. At 14.03.1991 , “The regulation and control of solid wastes management” was put into force. Said regulation reads :
Organizes legal aspects of collection , transport and disposal garbage and solid wastes in Turkey. Article 9 this regulation stipulates that the plastic and metal container solid wastes must be minimised.
Table 3 : Ratios to be achieved in years for collection of PET, PVC and metal containers
Years Metal and Aluminum (%) PET, PVC (%)
1992 15 25
1993 20 35
1994 30 45
1995 45 65
1996 60 70
Wastes produced after use of materials marketed in containers made of plastic paper, cardboard, glass or the combinations of such materials must be minimum to the extent possible and wastes must absolutely be recycled. The rate of recycling must be as high as possible. To achieve these high rates will be the responsibility of producers, fillers, users, distributers and consumers.
Çevkovakfì “Environmental Protection Foundation “ estabished through the effecting from “ The regulation for management of solid wastes” on 01.11.1991, their aims are collection and recycling of container wastes like PET bottles, metal and alu cans, etc.
By the succesful separate collection is the motivated people, one of them very importat poits. As the result of a good organized public relations activity , we can increase the contribution of people for the separate collection of solid wastes. After a well organized collecting of PET bottles , they can use after treatment as textile fibre filler. It should be built this network and infrastructure.
The three targents given in the following may be selected as objectives particularly for recycling of containers :
Cardboard liquid boxes have a thermal value of 25.000 kJoule/kg.
PE containers have a considerable high thermal value 42.000 kJoule/kg .
Çevko Vakfì Model - Project for collection and recycling of cans and plastic bottles is started in the areas of the coastel site (Antalya) and big city (ÿstanbul, Ankara) in Turkey.
ÿt should be organizing in whole Turkey an experimental collection of plastic , glass bottles , papers and metals, beverage containers.
This project should be prepared by Department of Environmental from the Mìnìntry of Environment and Çevko Vakfì in Turkey.
Being the experience of separate collection in Turkey at the beginning, has been requested to collaborate on the base of its experience on this field. I, as consultancy has been carried out in Turkey in the period 1991-1992 with meetings and visits related to solid waste, its collection, transportatìon and disposal, separate collection of glass bottles, production and consumption of beverages and liquid container wastes. The most asked poeple said that the best and easy solution of packaging materials are buy-back and/or deposit systems.
WASTES COLLECTION SYSTEM FOR 3 R
Separate collection of glass bottles, recycable materials :
A system for the separate collection of glass bottles shuold be established in ÿzmir, Mersin, Adana, Bursa, Ankara and ÿstanbul.
Glass bottles can be collected throught the using bottle banks, of about 3 cubic meter capacity, placed on the curbs (drop off system). In each place can be used two bottle banks, one for the clear glass, one for the green one. At the beginning time, by the inspection of some bottle banks we can confirmed such situation:
The bottle banks were found empty and the content. Consisting of glass, plastic and steel, containers, was similar for both the banks. In practice instead of a glass collection it is a low yield multimaterial collection. At a first analysis the reasons of these bad results are;
It is important to verify these last points with the company carrying out the recovery and with the glass manufacturer, which manages the collection.
These data will be very useful to evaluate the possibility of the collection of cans and plastic bottles, as the experience in EC shows that plastic collection yields can those of glass bottles.
CURBSIDE COLLECTION SYSTEM: Collection may be realized by pacing at curbs one or more containers for recyclable materials.
BUY-BACK SYSTEM: This program is directly aimed to consumers. By establishing more than 25 in Turkey for collecting particularly non-alcoholìc beverarages and liquid containers
DROP-OFF SYSTEM: This system is organize particularly withthe efforts of volunteers.
CARRY-AWAY SYSTEM: This a modification of separate collection . Her, the principle is to take waste plastics to central accumulation areas or to waste plastic processing plants.
RECEIVING SYSTEM: Whether this system is based on integrated , partially integrated or additive system or single type waste or multìtype waste storage system.
Bank System: This system was tested for glass bottles collection in Turkey.
STORAGE CONTAINER SYSTEM
Separate collection may be started with three containers system :
MUNICIPALITY SYSTEM
Munìcipalities collect mixed garbage reguarly. Collection will be effected by utilizing existing capacities of municipalities (vehicles, equipments, personnels).
Garbage Contactors: The fact that some poeple collect valuable wastes from curside containers and sell the same to garbage contractors will be evaluated.
PROMOTIONAL COLLECTION SYSTEM
Specially designed collection containers will be distributed to houses and summer residences (touristics area).
RECYCLING PROCESS: COLLECTING, CLASSIFICATION AND END USING
The three targents given in the following may be selected as objectives particularly for reutilisation of liquid containers wastes (3R):
1th - Reuse ; 2th - Recycling; 3th - Recovery
Recovery of Solid Wastes
It is clear that natural sources are limited. For this reason, they must be carefully used. To save the sources and to increase the life standard, developed countries found out some methods for recycling and recovering activities against the energy crisis. For recycling and recovering of solid wastes some regulations have been become effective by the European Community.
Developing countries which have some financial problems, must save their natural sources for optimum use of them. Hence, they can use them for a long period without any environmental problems.
Recovering, recycling and reuse of materials such as iron, steel, copper, lead, paper, plastic, hard rubber, glass, would prevent the loose of natural sources. Also, these procedures would save foreign exchange which is used for importation of raw materials, and energy which is used for production of consumption matters. Amount of solid wastes which is occured by human activities, would decrease and therefore the environmental problems. Decreasing amount and volume of solid wastes is an important procedure for some countries which have limited land which is used for sanitary landfill.
In the planning stage of recovering of solid wastes, following criteria must be considered :
Also, these factors are disadvantages of recovery.
Collecting and recovering of solid wastes is economically important procedure. The advantage of this procedure is not only to create supplement for economy but also to save more filling area because of decreasing volume of solid wastes.
For goals related to recycling , reuse, and recovery :
(Separation , sorting and selection )
The emergence of the Green Movement has been one of the most cheering social developments of the last twenty years :
Aluminum cans can be recycled in two ways:
1. Alone for producing new aluminum cans, in this case the cans are sent to the foundry where are transformed into panes and then sent to lamination.
2. Mixed with other aluminum goods for production of other products, in this case recycling is easy and many shops are found in all countries.
The upper part of the steel cans is made with aluminum. The separation of steel is done with a magnet after grinding. The two materials are than sent to the respective foundries. The value of steel is lower than that of aluminum.
. direct recycle for primary use
. use by a second industry as a raw material
. energy recovery
. utilization in pollution control systems
Production and consumption of beverages and oneother recycable materials in from the data received from the companies the following preliminary picture is obtained.
Cans: all cans are produced by NACANCO at the Manisa-plant using steel. The consumption of aluminum cans is low and these cans are all imported (capacity ½ liter). The 1991 consumption is evaluated 450 millions of cans, which is concentrated for the 80 in the coastal area where 25 millions inhabitants live. The per capita consumption of the coastal area is evaluated in 15 cans per year of which 12 (12x25=300 grams) are steel made and 3 (3x18=54 grams) aluminum made.
The can consumption is fast growing and NACANCO in Manisa is planning to increase its capacity to 700 millions cans by the 1993.
Plastic bottles: Two polymers are used, PVC for mineral water, and PET for soft drinks. All the mineral water is not carbonated.
PET: These bottles are produced by only SASA company current production is 250 millions bottles per year. The per capita consumption in the coastal area is evaluated 8 bottles per year.
PVC: There are some PVC bottles producers, the 1991 consumption is evaluated in 170 millions bottles, corresponding to a per capita consumption of 6 bottles per year.
The per capita consumption of the coastal area is evaluated in 8 PET bottles per year which have 370 grams weight (each one has 47 grams) and 6 PVC bottles per year which have 300 grams weight (each one has 50 grams) aluminum made.
Recycling of glass : Used glass, bottles and glass-made materials will be also seperately collected. For this procedure and for preventing of environmental pollution, a contract was signed between the Municipality of Metropolitan Izmir and Turkish Bottle and Glass Fabrics Co. in June 1988. Also, a campaign was prepared for seperate collecting. Containers which were used for collecting glass and glass-made materials, were left at 50 different places of the city. They had two different colors; the whites belong to the non-colored and the greens belong to the colored glasses.
Amount of the collected materials for three years, from 1989 to 1991, was 307 tons. Hospitals started to support this campaign in 1990 and the municipality has left the containers in the hospital areas. It has been accepted that good results had been taken.
COST
. Through municipal company
. Through private company
. Through private and municipal company
. Combinated private/municipal company
. Pick-up system during the day or by the night
. 120, 240, 500, 1100 litre or greater containers.
. Selective collection practices has been a widespread development in the developped countries specially for the bioorganic materials, for recycable materials and for those consdered hazardous .
. Selective collection of hazardous urban refuse has reached a very important proportion at the last time .
. Disposal charges are usually calculated in the basis of the volume of containers ( bins, or sacks ) and in the collection frequency.
. Disposal costs are the sums of collection, transportation and treatment operations ; and treatment costs for incinerations or to discharging in sanitary landfill, etc.
. cleaning of containers of all traces
. treat the washing waters
. operate the plastics sorting
. produce the respective regenerated products
The operating cost will be minimized. By this way it is avoided the necessity to press, to store the collected materials and to find a customer. These problems will be of importance only in a second step when the quantities to handle will be bore large.
For reuse the plastics for packaging and liquid bottles must be sorted according to the polymers and then reclaimed in order to remove caps, labels, adhesives, base caps and all other kind of materials.
For the purification of the bottles a washing plant is necessary in which the grinded bottles are washed in water, dried and, if requested, pelletized and reused as secondary raw materials.
The possibility for recycling in Turkey of these two polymers depends on the quantity collected, if it is enough to feed a washing plant, and moreover if the industry is ready to reuse the polymers.
It will be suggested to evaluate the present situation and the future possibilities for recycling of Alu - , Steel-cans, PET and PVC beverage bottles in Coastal area of Turkey in order to have all the elements for preparing a complete recycling plan. Collection systems should be privatezed to solve of cost problem.
Izmir Integrated Solid Wastes Management Project (IISWMP)
IIEP-Sanitary Landfill Plant
Industrial and househould solid waste (ISW & HSW) Sanitary Landfill area is 800 000 m2. Stroge volume of domestic SW (HSW) is 3 125 000 m3 and of industrial SW (ISW) is 790 000 m3 . In addition sludge from treatment plant and ash from IP (Incineration Plant) are accumulated in this plant.
Izmir Integrated Solid Wastes Management Project (IISWMP) ìnclude the selected waste disposal concept strategy:
*** Material recovery and recycling
*** Composting
*** Waste to Energy (WTE)
*** Sanitary landfill
Landfill site Harmandalì has on area 90 ha, theirs 50 ha of this land has already been filled by the City Solid Wastes (CSW) 30 ha is calculated to the about 5,6 million m3 and this can be used until the year 2003. Presently at existing Composting Plant Uzundere can be disposed ca. 6% of all Solid Wastes, genereted in ÿzmir (Izmir Büyüksehir Belediyesi, 1997) Upgrading and rehabilitation of existing landfill site at Harmandalì it can be used by 5 additional years or provide an additional 12 years.
Rehabilitation of old dumping area at Çi.gli, Uzundere, Buca, Isìkkent, etc.
Improvment of present collection and transfer stations.
Provision of special transportation vehichles for hazardous wastes and clinical wastes.
The Incineration Plant is designed for a average calorific value of about 8 000 kjoule/kg (range 6 000 - 11 000 kjoule/kg).
Genereted wastes per capita and per day in ÿzmir is about 0,60 kg/l.a.
Table shown the SW Amount in Izmir.
Table : The SW Amount in ÿzmir (IISWMP, 1997)
SW Type Daily Amount Yearly Amount
( tons/day ) ( tons/year )
HSW 1330 485 000
ISW lìke HSW 250 80 000
Hazardous waste 50 16 000
Clinical waste 4 1 460
Total 1634 582 460
Table . Composition and amount of hospital solid wastes (Çoban, 1992).
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗
║ Composition Amount (kg/day) ║
╠═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╣
║ Food wastes 6,770 ║
║ Office wastes 2,855 ║
║ Clinic wastes 8,375 ║
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
Table . Yearly variation of solid waste amount of Izmir (Çoban, 1992).
───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
Years Population Solid waste Solid waste Cumulative
(capita) amount amount amount
(ton/day) (ton/year) (ton)
────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────_
1991 2,775,613 2,776 1,013,240 1,013,240
1996 3,123,966 3,123 1,139,895 6,206,095
2001 3,621,555 3,621 1,321,665 12,087,340
2006 4,324,324 4,324 1,578,260 18,952,260
2011 5,013,054 5,013 1,829,745 27,095,045
2016 5,811,514 5,811 2,121,015 36,535,040
2021 6,737,141 6,737 2,459,005 47,478,105
────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────_
The specific production rate of solid wastes which are produced until the year of 2021, was assumed as 1 kg/capita.day. There is no any increment of amount of solid wastes for 5 years.
──────── ───────────────────────────────────────────_
Table . Yearly filling volume (Çoban, 1992).
───────────────────────────────────────────────────_
Years Solid waste Cumulative Landfill volume requirement
volume volume Cumulative
(m3/year) (m3) (m3/year) (x109 m3)
───────────────────────────────────────────────────_
1991 1,266,550 1,266,550 1,583,188 0.00158
1996 1,424,869 7,757,619 9,697,024 0.0176
2001 1,652,081 15,109,176 18,886,470 0.075
2006 1,972,825 23,690,325 29,612,906 0.18
2011 2,287,181 33,868,806 42,336,008 0.28
2016 2,651,269 45,668,799 57,085,999 0.51
2021 3,073,756 59,347,631 74,184,839 0.81
───────────────────────────────────────────────────_
Volumetric weight of solid waste was assumed as 0.8 ton/m3
───────────────────────────────────────────────────_
Capacity Of Harmandalì Sanitary Landfill Area
Athough, three alternatives which include filling and ultimate elevations, have been given in the project, it is impossible that to get ultimate elevations.
Alternative capacities of Harmandalì sanitary landfill have been assumed as follows :
Considering the waste production of Izmir and volumetric weight of compacted solid waste as 1,940 ton/day and 560 kg/m3, respectively, mean usage period of Harmandalì sanitary landfill area, for whole alternatives, have been calculated and listed below :
The third alternative includes a future planning that energy transfer lines which is upon the area required for this alternative, would be delocated.
Equipment Requirement
According to size of sanitary landfill areas and apllied method, selectin of required equipment is important. They must have enough capacity and meet standards. Tractors which carry and compact the wastes, have been recommended. They can have tires or paunch mats.
The sanitary landfill operation jobs classification are important:
At the end of controlling of the project, if foundation of the landfill, drainage system, isolation layers and additional units are suitable to the regulation, operating permit will be taken from an organization which is responsible. In the permit, the type of solid wastes which will be stored, is declared.
Domestic Solid Wastes To Be Storaged Into The Sanitary Landfill Areas
According to 22nd paragraph of the Regulation of Controlling of Solid Wastes, domestic solid wastes which are originated from the settlement areas, plant wastes which are wasted from parks, gardens and green areas, huge solid wastes, non-toxic and non-hazardous industrial wastes which have similar properties with domestic solid wastes, industrial wastewater treatment plant sludges which are non-toxic and non-hazardous could be stored into the sanitary landfill areas. Excavation wastes do not accept.
Domestic and industrial solid wastes must be recycled, recovered and reused before collecting. In case of that recycling and recovering procedures are not feasible, to prevent the human and environmental health, to reduce the volume of wastes and to produce energy and compost, solid wastes can be incinerated or composted. Side products which are originated or emitted from these procedures, must be collected and controlled, respectively.
Wastes Which are not Stored With Domestic Solid Wastes
According to 22nd paragraph of the Regulation of Controlling of Solid Wastes, to prevent human and environment health, following materials are not stored with domestic solid wastes.
Hazardous wastes which are produced in Izmir, will be stored into area which gave a hydraulic conductivity coefficient of 10-10 at depth 4 to 6 m at the end of unpressured water test and is close to boring hole numbered 18th.
Municipalities can not mix hospital, clinic and laboratory wastes, radioactive wastes, storage batteries, normal batteries, medicines and pills with domestic solid wastes.
Hospital And Clinic Wastes
The non-sistematically disposal of hospital wastes is very dangerous for human and environmental health because of they include some operated organs and infectious wastes. To prevent this hazardous situation, in 22 hospitals in Izmir, an inventory study has been carried out and, at the end, it was determined that the amount of daily hospital wastes was 15 to 18 ton (Erdin,1987) and 18 to 20 ton ( Çalì_ and Çoban, 1990).
To prevent the human and environmental health, to take under control the contagious diseases, to evaluate the esthetic view, a regulation which belongs to collecting, transporting and disposing of infectious hospital wastes, called “Control Regulations of Hospital Wastes”, was prepared by Boºaziçi University, Faculty of Engineering, Research Group for Controlling of Waste and Pollution on March 13th, 1990. This regulation has been become effective by the decree of Council of Municipality of Metropolitan Izmir. It is valid until the decree of Ministry of Environment becomes effective. Councillor of Environment of Environmental Ministry published a circular which was related with the hospital wastes, on September 3rd, 1991. This circular was the brief version of regulation which was become effectiv by the Municipality of Metropolitan Izmir.
Hospital wastes which will be seperately collected and transported, will be disposed into “Harmandalì Sanitary Landfill Area”. They will be buried into deep pits which have a impermeable floor and contain lime, and covered with soil, daily.
These wastes will not be normally accepted to the sanitary landfill. But, in exceptional cases such that there is no any disposal alternative for disposing of hospital and clinic wastes, they can be disposed meeting the standards.
Hospital and clinic wastes will be stored into most immermeable part of Harmandalì sanitary landfill area in accordance with the regulation which was become effective on September 3th, 1991 by Ministry of State, “Regulation of Controlling of Hospital Wastes”.
According to 15th paragraph of the Regulation of Controlling of Hospital Wastes, “Aspects which are related with sanitary landfill”, in case that there is no any disposal alternative such as incineration, they must be stored in the sanitary landfill area as a hazardous wastes.
According to 16th paragraph of the Regulation of Controlling of Hospital Wastes, “Characteristics of landfill area”, selected area for storing hospital and clinic wastes must have following properties:
Industrial Wastes
Waste types and the amounts of 135 industrial plants, which were obtained from a study carried out in 1990, have been given below.
Industrial wastes which have similar properties with the domestic wastes, and treatment sludges will be stored with together domestic solid wastes. Because of there is no any regulation about collecting and disposing of hazardous wastes and chemical treatment sludges, until “Regulation of Controlling of Hazardous Wastes and Chemical Matters” becomes effective, this kind of wastes will be stored at a part of the landfill area which has minimum permeability and covered with soil, daily.
The government, most authorative organization of the city and municipality have responsibilities for disposing of these materials, separately. They can apply the “deposit method”.
In the border of municipality, the municipalities and out of the border, most authorative organization of the city have authority for the following activities:
Producers which produce domestic and industrial wastes which have similar properties with domestic type, must keep own wastes ready for collecting, in a way which is determined by the municipality or most authorative organization of the city.
Treatment Sludges
According to 28th paragraph of the Regulation of Controlling of Solid Wastes, to store chemical treatment sludges with domestic solid wastes, water content of the sludges must have 65%.
Most of the treatment sludges which are originated from the treatment plants has been dumped into landfill areas. But, this dumping process must be controlled.
Treatment sludges are stored in two ways:
These two methods could be applied at the same time. Another method is storing of sludges into a part of the sanitary landfill area, separately.
To store the treatment sludges, securitly, following criteria must be applied.
In Harmandalì sanitary landfill area, domestic wastewater treatment sludges will be mixed with solid wastes and industrial wastewater treatment sludges will be separately stored into special part of the landfill area, as a hazardous waste.
Excavation and Stocking of Soil
The follwing principles and general rules should be considered :
The sanitary landfill operation involves placement, compection, and covering of the SW completely with soil prior to the end of each working day. The thickness of the daily soil cover is 20 - 30 cms.
Making a decision about removal of surface and sub-layers of soil before dumping process depends on the post-usage of the area and materials necessary for initial and final coverage. In some cases, in order to use the absorption and filtration capacity of the soil it is preferred not to make any removal.
Supplying Of Covering Material
To achieve continuous storage of solid wastes, suitable material must be ready everytime. Most ideal covering material is silty and sandy soil. It must not include rocks greater then 15 cm. If there is no suitable material into the landfill region, they must be supplied from another source. In Harmandalì sanitary landfill area, there is no enough material, because the lowest layer which is consisted of clay, must be kept, and covering material will not taken from the hills with recpect to keep the natural slope. According to soil investigation report, there is immpermeable material at the surface of the area. Probably, required covering material will be supplied an outer source. A part of them will be supplied from construction wastes and rubbles, and soil which are originated from the excavation of drainage sewers. A part of required covering material will be stored into the landfill area as standby part.
Landfill Leachate and Treatment
The essencial factors which are caused landfill leachate are; climate of the land, topography, type of the soil, hydrogeology, presence of clay layer under the landfill area, presence of soil layer over the landfill, type of the soil, and the type of the solid waste.
The most important source of the leachate is decomposition of bioorganic wastes and rainfall. The secondary sources are the effects of ground waters, underground waters, and water content of the solid waste.
A few organics, inorganics and toxic pollutants are present in leachate from landfill site and/or composting facilities. Characterization and treatment of leachate, originated from uncontrolled dumping areas and controlled landfills, where anaerobic process occur, has been the subject of many studies during last 40 years. Treatment of leachate stil is problem in ÿzmir, ÿstanbul, Bursa and so on. They are some projects, which will be solve the pollution potential of leachate originated from composting, and from landfill leachate. The landfill site, the contaminants concentrations in the leachate will decrease as a result of stabilization step by step at the time.
Leachate of Landfill stil is problem in ÿzmir, but in next future will be solve it. Monthly leachate quantity at Harmandalì sanitary landfill area is 117 kg/m3.
Leachate waters from the collection pond are removed by four alternative methods:
a) Discharge to city sewerage system and treatment in city treatment plant.
b) Recirculation of leachate waters at the landfill area
c) Removal by treatment at landfill site
Pump capacity calculation in pumping leachates of Harmandalì landfill to the area for improvement purposes:
ÿzmir sanitary landfill area:
Monthly average leachate quantity: 117 kg/m3
Landfill area : 900 000 m2
117 kg/m3 x 900 000 m2 = 1.053 x 108 kg = 105.300 t/month
= 3500 t/day
Number of pumps used = 5 (approximately 300 m in between each other)
3500 t/day / 5 pumps = 700 t/day
700 t/day / 10 work hours = 70 t/hour
In Harmandalì landfill area, by taking into consideration the surface slope, 5 pumps (with stand-by) with 70 t/h capacity will be used by placing them with 300 m distances from each other.
Biogases Production Through The Open Filling of Solid Wastes in Turkey
And Removing Them By Applying Sanitary Landfill Like in Izmir, Istanbul, Izmit, Bursa
Biophysicochemical reactions which occur in the completed landfills some reactions products, which can be very doungerous for the environment.
Control of gas and leachate leakages also should be make very curryfull.
Design and operation method is very importent for the exactly building of the landfill.
According to the microbiological anaylsis report, all groundwater samples, except drinking water of Village Ulucak, were found contaminated with sewage. Other parameters also show that groundwater could not be used as a drinking water source.
Gas Control Preventions
Solid Waste Control Regulations Article 27 which is related with removal of deposit gas:
It is stated that, “Gases that may develop as a result of anaerobic decomposition of organic materials in the solid waste, like carbondioxide, hydrogen sulfide, ammonium, nitrogen compounds and mainly methane, that may dissipate in the environment and cause explosions and toxic effects are collected with horizontal and vertical collection systems and are given to the atmosphere in a controlled manner or used for energy production.”
In all sanitary landfill areas after all the oxygen is consumed, decomposition becomes anaerobic and mainly methane and carbondioxide are produced at this stage.
From the products that form as a result of anaerobic decomposition of organic substances, partially stabilized organic materials, organic acids and various gases (CO2, CH4, N2, H2S) can be stated. In standard conditions, there is a linear relationship between decomposition rate and gas production rate. Gas production rate increases in the firs two years and it continues at a slower rate for 25 or more years. Gas quantity practically measured changes for 1 t of solid waste in between 60 - 180 m3 depending on the characteristics of the solid waste deposited.
Average landfill gas analyses:
CH4 = 55-60 % as volume
CO2 = 35-40 % as volume
H2 = 2 - 3 % as volume
H2S,CO2,NO2 = 1 % as volume
90 % of the gas originating from landfill areas is formed by CH4 and CO2. Since atmospheric concentration of this gas is 5-15 % an explosive mixture is created.
In landfill areas where gas drainage is not existing, beginning from landfill site boundary to 100-125 m of distance methane gases observed in 40 % concentration. In these types of landfills, distribution of gas depends on soil properties and surface coverage type. Among the gases produced in landfill areas, CO2 becomes concentrated at the base because of it being heavier (1.5 times heavier than atmosphere), and sometimes mixes with groundwaters and lower the pH and increase water hardness. A typical gas aeration stack is formed from gravels and distances between each stack changes from 18 m to 60 m. For gravel layer thickness 30-45 cm is suggested. Alternatively aeration barriers or wells may be used.In Harmandalì landfill area aeration stacks will be placed at every 50 m but as a prevention for the coverage being impermeable these stacks will be placed more frequently.
At Harmandalì sanitary landfill site, connectable, 150 mm diameter and 3 m long hard PVC pipes will be used for aeration purposes. These pipes will be fixed from the base and they will be surrounded with gravel to protect them from blocking.
Environmental Effects of Methane gas
Methane itself does not have any direct toxic effect on plants but at the root region it removes oxygen and causes oxygen deficiency. In reculturation situations, methane gases leaking in small quantities stimulate plant development but severe leakages destruct their growth.
Leachate waters from landfills combine with CO2 of decomposed products and cause an increase in water hardness:
CaCO3 + CO2 + H2O Ca(HCO3)2
Landfill gas is the product of natural anaerobic biochemical decomposition of organic materials and typically contains nearly equal amounts of carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) with traces of other decomposition by-products .
Both methane and carbondioxide gases are odorless.
If not controlled , landfill gas is capable of subsurface migration and escape into the atmospher , causing potential odor and safety problems. The principal movement of landfill gas is along the path of the least resisitance ; which is usually directly upwards through the landfill’s top surface.
Calculation Of Amount Of Biogas
Coe = Co (0.014T+0.28)
Coe : total amount of degredable carbon (kg C/ton solid waste)
Co : amount of organic carbon at the beginning (200 kg C/ton solid waste)
T : temperature (°C)
Coe = 200(0.014 x 35 + 0.28) = 154 kg C/ton solid waste
G =V.Coe
G : ultimate volume of biogas (m3/ton solid waste)
V : amount of gas as a result of degredation of 1 kg organic carbon (1.868 Nm3/kg organic C)
G = 1.868 x 154 = 387.6 Nm3/ton solid waste
Gt = G[1 - exp(-0.07t)]
Gt = amount of biogas at time t
Table . Yearly biogas production rates.
──────────────────────────────────────────────────_
Years Solid waste Cumulative Biogas volume Methane volume
amount amount at the end of year
(ton/year) (ton) (x109 Nm3) (x109) (Nm3)(*)
──────────────────────────────────────────────────_
1991 1,013,240 1,013,240 0.0000197 0.00985
1996 1,139,895 6,206,095 0.53 0.265
2001 1,321,665 12,087,340 1.7 0.88
2006 1,578,260 18,952,260 3.5 1.8
2011 1,829,745 27,095,045 5.9 2.9
2016 2,121,015 36,535,040 8.7 4.3
2021 2,459,005 47,478,105 12 6.0
─────────────────────────────────────────────────_
(*) : assuming CH4=0.50 Biogas
────────────────────────────────────────────────_
Izmit Integrated Environmental Project (IIEP)
IIEP-Sanitary Landfill Plant
Industrial and househould solid waste (ISW & HSW) Sanitary Landfill area is 800 000 m2. Stroge volume of domestic SW (HSW) is 3 125 000 m3 and of industrial SW (ISW) is 790 000 m3 . In addition sludge from treatment plant and ash from IP (Incineration Plant) are accumulated in this plant.
Isolation Of Area In Which Special Solid Wastes Area Filled
In selection of an area in which special solid wastes will be filled, it is required to search and to find out a soil which has too low natural permeability (k < 10-7 m/s). Construction density (DPr) must be greater than 0.95. In order to prevent impermeable layer which has a thickness of 1.5 m (k < 5x10-10 m/s), against to the damage, a geo-membrane layer which has a thickness of at least 2 mm, must be spread over this layer.
The most suitable one of the above materials is (PEHD), high density polyethylene. It gives better results for “Toluol” tests and weight change tests, more than that of the others have. Another characteristics of PEHD is flexible. It swells under the effects of leachate and chemicals and returns to old situation when the effects are eliminated, so it is reversible. Other specifications are also good.
Geo-textiles have been successfully used since early 1970’s. They are suitable for the environment and economical. They have characteristics;
Control of Water Ways Coming From Outer Regions and of Leachate
To prevent all water ways which come from outer regions to reach to Harmandalì sanitary landfill area, a main collector will be constructed. Hence, only water which is originated from stormwater, will reach to the drainage system. In addition, to keep the roads against the stormwater overflowing and to prevent surface waters to reach lower elevations, drainage canals will be constructed. During the road construction of Harmandalì sanitary landfill area, ditches have been opened near the roads.
The most important problem in the design and operation of sanitary landfill areas is the control of infiltration water originating from the waste materials. Infiltration waters originating from domestic solid wastes is a combination of organic, inorganic, and soluble particles. Infiltration waters cause pollution of surface and groundwaters by decomposition of soluble ions and organic materials.
Quantity of infiltration water depends on the water content of the solid waste and the rain fall amount in that area. Its chemical characteristic depends on the other hand, to its biologic decomposition ability, chemical oxidation process and decomposition of organic and inorganic materials.
Determination of Leaching Quantity and Quality
Even though the relationship in between annual rain height and leach water depends on evaporation, this can be taken as a constant while making calculations for certain regions. Other than evaporation, the most important parameter in determining relationships between precipitation-leaching is compaction degree in the landfill area. Solid waste density in the deposit area is usually more than 0.6 t/m3. Depending on the results of many studies done in West Germany, 15-25 % of annual precipitation flows as leachate water (Franzius,1974). In landfills compacted by a compactor, this ratio changes in between 15-20 %, in landfills compacted by tracked vehicles it is in between 30-50 %, and in compacted surface landfills 20-25 %.
Even though leachate waters originate from solid wastes with high humidity ratio, mainly it is produced from percolation of rain water into solid waste layers. Collection and treatment of leachate waters are cost increasing factors. All these factors effect the cost parallel to leachate quantity. Though leachate quantity is taken equal to the water quantity entering the soil, to determine leachate water quantity for Izmir Harmandalì sanitary landfill area.
Whole the collected leachate from the landfill area will be processing by a WWTP on the Landfill Site in Izmit.
Istanbul Integrated Wastes Management Project (IIWMP)
Istanbul Integrated Wastes Management Project (IIWMP) are included the collection, separation, transfer station, composting, incinarition of clinical SW, and sanitary landfill systems.
(Öztürk, ÿ.; O. Arìkan; A. Bastürk and at all ,1997)Whole the collected leachate from the landfill area are treated by a WWTP - Balta Liman in ÿstanbul.
Egaen Integrated Solid Wastes Management Project (EISWMP)
Alyanak at al (1997) have finished a team research work about the problems and their regional solution of all kind wastes mostly generated by the industries in cities like ÿzmir, Aydìn and Denizli. Handling combination is with landfill and incineration.
Case Study Kemalpasa/IZMIR
Kemalpasa is located 29 km from IZMIR city it has 660 km2 areas including 35 km river basin on the east-west IZMIR to ANKARA road. Kemalpasa district surrounded by Manisa from north, Bayindir and Torbali from south and finally Turgutlu and Bornova from east and west, respectively.
Kemalpasa county has been passing from agricultural ecosystem to industral ecosystem for long period of time. Today, this situation is still continuing. Industry was constructed on valuable fields and water sources without doing Environmental impact Assessment studies. Therefore, too may thing were destructed, Nowadays Nif Brooks is used as waste water discharge and solid waste receiving media while it was a place to where people were going for picnic and hunting fish for 15 years ago.
Above 167 factories, 200 poultries and l50 cattle farms were constructed with the development of industry since l970. The population was increased rapidly parallel to industrialization.
This event was also happened in one of the most agricultural area in Kemalpasa county. It became nonagricultural area due to rapid industrialization. The water, air and soil pollution caused by industry goes out of Kemalpasa county lines mixed to Gediz River by Nif Brook and then carried to Aegean sea and polluted it.
Polluted soil caused by environmental pollution leads to decrease in the yield and consequently economic loss of farmers.
One of the most important issue in county is absence of perfect completed solid waste projects. The generated wastes, from industries treatment plant sludge and from factories plants toxic - hazardous wastes and domestic wastes disposed arbitrary to land, forest areas and in to Nif Brooks. Solid wastes was collected and disposed without controlling in 67 landfills on 17 ha area.
By investigation the potential of the unorganized landfill sites in Kemalpasa, not only the present situation is important, the accumulated solid waste amount from the passed years should also be taken in to consideration. So there must related the present landfill position with passed years solid waste amount and also with present situation solid waste generation potential. In this paper, it was aimed to show environmental pollution problem of Kemalpasa because of arbitrary dispose of solid wastes and to recount starts for sanitation of landfill areas.
Kemalpasa county has been passing from agriculture economy to industry economic for long period of time. Today, this situation is still continuing. Industry established arbitrary on productive agricultural areas because of advantageous of getting cheep water, electricity and area around Bornova and Kemalpasa/IZMIR.
Industry was constructed on valuable fields and water sources without doing Environmental impact Assessment studies. Therefore, too may thing were destructed, Nowadays Nif Brooks is used as waste water discharge and solid waste receiving media while it was a place to where people were going for picnic and hunting fish for 20 years ago.
Above 160 factory, 200 poultry and l50 cattle farm was constructed with the development of industry since l970. The population was increased rapidly parallel to industrialization.
It is well known, “National Environment Plan” hasn’t been done in TURKEY yet. Also environment organization plan for each region is absent. There is only place improvement plan for organization. However, these plans are not mostly applied completely. Therefore unorganized and distorted urbanization was occurred in most places of our country and factories was constructed on agricultural areas (IZMIR IL YILLIGI, 1994).
This event was also happened in one of the most agricultural area in Kemalpa¦a plain. It became nonagricultural area due to rapid industrialization. The water, air and soil pollution caused by industry goes out of Kemalpa¦a county lines mixed to Gediz River by Nif Brook and then carried to Aegean sea and polluted it.
Polluted soil caused by environmental pollution leads to decrease in the yield and consequently economic loss of farmers. High agricultural yield of county depends on limited water sources. The industry without infrastructure aspire to already limited water while it is one which both consumed and pollute water.
Kemalpa¦a Organized Industrial Region “KOSBI”, which was planed in 1991 and because functional in 1994, was constructed to prevent unorganized industrial development and to plan and to control industrialization. Today, it has 410 ha area of which 69 % is already used. Fortunately, it is thought as to increase its capacity from 410 ha to 1000 ha with 144 % rising in total area due to high industrialization demand. The border of “KOSBI” starts from Belkahve and reached to Tetra Pak Nasa¦ Industry line. Yet the area in increasing area capacity is not along but it was planed to enlarge it around Ankara road (TRAV, 1994).
However, when environmental effects of preset industry in this region is considered, it is obviously seen that how capacity increase in “KOSBI” will have environmental destruction in Kemalpa¦a.
It will be a big problem to supply water to new construction in KOSBI due to already polluted and un enough water resources. It is compulsory to find new resources beside to reusing and saving water.
One of the most important problems in county is absence of solid waste projects. The product wastes, from industries treatment sludge from plants toxic-hazardous wastes and domestic wastes disposed arbitrary to lad, forest areas and in to Nif Brooks. Solid wastes was collected without controlling in 67 unorganized dumping places on 19 ha area due to absence of planned solid waste landfill.
Soil Material
Composition of the soil material in the county is formed by the alluvium material and of the sandy clay and sandy silty clay.
Northern and eastern parts of the residential area are formed by the alluvial materials and that of the southern parts area formed by the reddish brown colored soil materials (terra-rosa soils). Western parts of the residential areas are formed by the brown colored soil materials. Alluvial soils are formed by A and B Horizons. This soils are formed by the completely transported materials. Thus, these materials mentioned above are transported and irregularly deposited in the base of the valley and slopes of the mountain.
A-horizon having 53cm. thickness is in deep
B-horizon is located in after the A-horizon.
The compositions of these zones have very kind of materials such as sandy clay silty clay and/or silty, clayey sands. Red colored soils having A and B zones are formed under the “climate conditions of mediterranean”.
Soil material of Kemalpa¦a plain which have deep horizons is permeable. Level of groundwater table which hasn’t saltiness, acidity and alcality problems is normal in the area.
Vegetation and Agriculture
Vegetation basically consist of forest, marshy and agricultural areas. Total area of Kemalpa¦a is 66,000 ha of which distribution is given in the following
Forest and Marshy : 37,916 ha (57.40 %)
Agricultural area : 25,714 ha (39.00 %)
River Basin and unusable land : 2,265 ha ( 3.50 %)
Meadow and Pasture : 110 ha ( 0.10 %)
Although economy of Kemalpa¦a depends on agriculture, only 8,500 farmer family earn money by farmising. Developing industry in Kemalpa¦a is food sector which processes agricultural yields of this region. The forest includes ruddy pine and scrub and most frequently growing fruits cherry oil, grape and peach.
After first industry was established in Kemalpa¦a 1970, the number of industry increased rapidly between 1974-1977 years. However, new factories was constructed on the productive agricultural lands. Unfortunately use of most productive areas for construction of new industries still continue. That’s why, industrialization effected agriculture of Kemalpa¦a negatively.
There are 4 types of soil (1 th,2 nd, 3 rd, 4 th) in terms of soil guality. South/South-West and North/North-West of Kemalpa¦a consist 4 th and 2 nd class soil. Two times harvesting per year is possible and best cherry of Turkey grows in this region.
300,000 produces, 120,000 cherry three present the climate and the location of Kemalpa¦a is very suitable to grows different types of vegetable and fruit and also presence of vegetation. Natural beauteous and forest regress attract people for touristic purposes.
However vegetation and forest areas are continuously destructed to get field or to construct industry. The number of endogenous plants decreases or they are completely last during these destruction. Natural ecosystem replace industrial ecosystem.
The presence of 27 types agricultural plant, 24 kind fruit and 3 types vegetable, totally 82 plant types was determined in Kemalpa¦a. Developed agriculture is one of the most important effect in the growth of mainly food industry. However the Kemalpa¦a plain because a land on which it is unable to make agriculture due to urbanization and industrialization.
Investigation of Solid Waste Potential
By investigation the potential of the un organized land fill sites in Kemalpa¦a, not only the present situation is important, the accumulated solid waste amount from the passed years should also be taken in to consideration. So there must related the present deponi position with passed years solid waste amount and also with present situation solid waste generation potential.
The daily production of solid waste is examined in two parts;
1- Solid waste from settled population
2- Solid waste from industries
The total amount of 86,726 l/day solid waste consists of 3 part; 80,411 l/day domestic waste, 4,430 l/day commercial wastes and 1,885 l/day is slaughterhouse waste. Commercial wastes consist of wastes collected from the shops, bazaar, street and officiate buildings.
143,351 l/day industrial wastes consist of 3 fractions; 9,704 l/day from employers, 61,715 l/day total product waste and 71,932 l/day total sludge from treatment facilities. The product waste and sludge are consist individual to removed amount and to be disposed amount part.
The 27,000 product waste and 15,696 l/day sludge amount of wastes are removed and benefit to economy and other amount of wastes are pored to disposel area.
The 34,715 amount of product wastes are disposed but it’s also consist of 2 parts: 2,351 l/day amount of degradable and 32,364 l/day amount is non degradable.
56,236 l/day amount of disposed sludge is also consist 2 part: the amount of 10,395 l/day is degradable and 45,841 l/day is non degradable sludge.
The amount of 22,450 l/day waste has domestic characteristic and it is coming from employers, product and from sludge degradable wastes.
When the 22,450 domestic characteristic waste accumulate with amount of 86,726 population solid waste for obtaining the total 109,176 l/day domestic solids waste.
When the total 109,176 and 78,205 l/day amount of total non degradable solid wastes accumulate there are obtaining the amount of 187,381 l/day total solid waste formation for dispose in Kemalpa¦a county.
By the investigation of all these waste potential, there had to make used of questionnaire form, legal documents, some information and literature surveyor sources.
For the population domestic solid waste calculation there had been used (1). and (2). formula (ERDIN, 1990).
V = 0.28.N(0.14) (1)
G = 0.43.N(-0.013) (2)
V = Specific solid waste volume (l/Ca.day), G = Bulk density (kg/l), N = population (person), Ca = Capita
According to 61,356 peoples solid waste generating 1994 basis, there are considering to used 1.310 l/day special solid waste volume and 0.373 kg/l bulk density.
Determination of The Distribution of Solid Wastes Between The Years 1965-1995
Solid wastes produced, in the earlier times, have been withdrawn arbitrarily, consequently unorganized landfills are formed. The solid wastes coming to the unorganized landfills are examined as domestic and industrial respectively.
Distribution of The Solid Waste Coming From The Settled
Population
The sources of the solid waste coming from the settled population are houses, shops and slaughterhouse.
If this equations is used it can be seen that the waste volume per capita is increasing with the population increase. The specific waste volume at the beginning of 1994 Vs = 1.31 l/capita.day. The accumulated waste volume of 617,947 m3 has decreased to 432,598 m3 due to degradation. It is explained the commercial waste volume of 34,047 m3 generated in the past decreased 30 % and 23,833 waste remained at the unorganized landfill.
The slaughterhouse wastes, as weight and volume, show a increasing from the 1984. The 5,307 m3 carnage wastes generated in lost 11 years biodegraded 80 % and its volume is 1,061 m3 As result, the rest of the residential wastes (657,351 m3) from the biodegradation is 457,492 m3 as landfill volume.
The data about the carnage wastes are reported according to the interview with the carnage directors and the questionnaire results.
Distribution of The Industrial Solid Wastes
This title is investigated under the subtitles of the solid wastes generated from the working stuff, and the solid wastes generated from the activities of the industries.
Solid Wastes Generated From The Working Stuff
The industries have generated solid wastes since 1974 significantly, and the solid wastes of working stuff is calculated from that date. The generated domestic solid waste of the working stuff is 33,526 m3 until today, and the rest waste from the biodegradation is 24,868 m3.
The calculations are made according to the answers of the questionnaires. The personal domestic solid waste production of the working stuff is found as 0.31 l/capita.day.
Manufacturing and Treatment Sludge Wastes
The sectoral solid waste distribution of the food, metal, mine, chemistry, textile, rubber and plastic, cellulose and paper, and tannery industries are given.
5.7, 91,348 m3 of the 253,178 m3 solid waste from the manufacturing is recovered, rest of it is tipped at landfills. The 27,865 m3 of the 128,987 m3 treatment sludge is recovered, rest of it is discharged to the landfills. That shows the 119,213 m3 of the 382,165 m3 total solid was recovered,and rest part of 262,952 m3 is tipped at landfills. If the data above is summarized; the 30 % of the biologic wastes decreased by biodegradation and the 20 % of the inert wastes decreased by settlement when the total amount of the solid waste generated at recent years is 955,829 m3.
The analysis of Pp, Cd, Cu, Ni, Zn, Hg and Cr parameters are done at the sludge samples which are mentioned at the Regulations of Solid Waste Control (Türk Çevre Mevzuatì, 1992). The results of the analysis of the samples, which were taken by formal ways and were tested at the laboratories of Hìfzìssìhha, are given at the graphics of the analysis results at Figure 5.2. It show that the concentrations of Pp, Cd, Cu, Ni, Hg, Zn and Cr. In the sludge of metal (Qm9) firm are greater than the total concentrations of other firms. But the greatest Zn concentration is seen in the sludge of Ceramic (Qmi4) firm and the second Zn greater concentration is seen in the sludge of old paper (Qcp3) firm. The lowest heavy metal concentration in the treatment sludge is seen at the Qmi2 firm. These results show that the pollution character of the treatment sludge differs from firm to firm.
Capsuling in its place
Capsuling is used to minimize the emissions from deponies. It is generally last choice in the removal of hazardous solid wastes after all construction methods are considered. Capsuling is made by covering four side of the area to prevent leak out. The method for coverage can be made by metal or concrete. A unleak out material is injected to the bottom of the deponi by a special method. After that the upper part is covered completely by concrete to make it as a box. This unleaking out method inhibits the relations between in and out of landfill Rainfall, air and any other things can’t go in to deponi beside to gases on leaches can’t go out of it. Since this method can’t be applied to biodegradable material containing deponies, leak out of water or gas has already not happened.
The capsuled landfill should be covered with sand and permitted to grow of plants and vegetation. However necessary precautions places must be placed to this area.
Capsulation can be done on separate local places when capsulation will be applied to some hazardous waste containing landfill of Kemalpa¦a, the following titles should be considered firstly. If the volume of hazardous waste in the aimed landfill is too big, and transfer of wastes from this place to organized landfill is more expensive than the capsulation, than it is preferred to capsulate the landfill. On the other hand, in the reverse case, it is better to transfer wastes to an organized landfill. By that way, the area will be completely recreated. There are hazardous waste containing landfills in Kemalpa¦a. The presence of biologically degradable matters in there landfills prevents the capsulation of them. And also capsuling method is not economic because of lass hazardous wastes. So for these places, to hat method and drainage on the sides of area can be placed.
Transfer to Sanitary Landfills
The Sanitary landfills are suitable solid waste storage places where all the environmental effects are considered, all kind of hazardous and nonhazardous waste can be left and all the control mechanisms are taken.
The construction of on sanitary landfill in Kemalpa¦a will function as both collection of usual wastes and a place to where wastes of unorganized wastes will be transferred. As a result the old area will be recreated. Therefore, it is necessary to carry the wastes from number U3, U5, U6, K13, Y17, Y18, A19, and Ö20 deponies to an unorganized landfill which must be constructed ( Table 5.21). These deponies, same of which close to Nif River or on the agricultural areas, pollute both groundwater, surface water and soil. That’s way, they must immediately removed. Actually, these areas are planed as recreation areas in the master plan. If they don’t removed today, more problem will be seen and new recreation areas will be used for solid waste left. By tat way, 39,000 m² area will be gained for different purposes while 35,500 m3 solid waste is transferred.
The other small wastes containing places present on the sides of roods and small river or in the county. They don’t have too much damage to environment. It is sufficient to cover them by soil or to medicate them. However, to leave the wastes arbitrary in countries must be forbidolen to prevent wide spread of this behavior beside to increasing number of these small of places. Otherwise small area will be big, uncontrollable and problematic big unorganized deponies.
Use of Recreated Areas
Around 62,200 m² empty area can be obtained if their wastes are collected or transferred to a landfill. These empty areas can be used for agricultural purposes after improving there floors and covering them with productive soil. They can be open to vegetation. Also in condition, kindergartens, spoor complexes, parks and buildings can be constructed on these areas.
CONCLUSIONS
In the content of this study, dominantly, the uncontrolled landfill sites in Kemalpa¦a were observed and their current states were determined as explained in section 5.3.1. Questionnaire studies were done by 130 firms but among these only 92 of them were found to be correct and these and six municipality questionnaires were used in the study. As a result of this questionnaire study the aspects given below were determined.
Uncontrolled industrialization and urbanization is continuing on in the district without any preventions for environmental pollution and there are totally 67 uncontrolled landfills of which 21 of them are large.
Among these 169,820 m2 uncontrolled landfills areas the ones having worst conditions. These cover way of rich ground and surface water resources. Also, for the past years, it was determined that solid wastes were being incinerated under uncontrolled conditions and also solid waste were left to biologically decompose in the open areas. As a result of these happenings it was calculated that approximately 29,447 nm3 of waste gas was given to the atmosphere which effected the air quality of the area negatively is unavoidable. The average precipitation in the district was found to be 659.1 mm/year. As a result of this precipitation falling on the uncontrolled landfill areas where all kinds of hazardous, organic and inorganic wastes were being deposited, the leaching water having a volume of 22,386-55,964 m3/year, was assumed to be polluting the ground and surface waters of the district Also since they were infiltrating to the soil it was thought that they were consumed by the plants and entered the food chain.
As a result, the uncontrolled landfill sites in this district should be improved and an appropriate solid waste disposal method should be chosen and applied in this region immediately. But the most of the important result is that during the end of this theses there is starting improve studies for all of important each un controlled landfill areas by Kemalpa¦a Kaymakamlìk and Municipalities.
As it was stated before, the purpose of this study was determining the existing situation in Kemalpa¦a district in terms of environmental pollution caused by solid wastes produced. In order to enlarge the scope of the study analytical investigations should also be performed as the second and the third steps. This way it will be possible to determine the source and extent of surface and groundwater pollution. Then it will be more appropriate to propose a certain improvement method.
In Kemalpa¦a, industrialization and urbanization were both developed in an uncontrolled manner. The pollution problems as a result of this development were very intense. For example in Kemalpa¦a, a food industry which has waste gas emissions functions next to a chemical industry. If an environmental impact study had been done previously, these two different factories would not be placed next to each other.
Kemalpa¦a Organized Industrial District (KOSB_), which began functioning in 1994 will enlarge its areas, if possible to 1,000 ha by an addition of 590 ha to its already existing area. This will cause industrialization in the region to increase plus 2.5 times which will cause 2.5 times more pollution problems . This may be very dangerous for Kemalpa¦a from environmental point of view. But as a result of it is supposed that the Organized Industrial District, industrialization will continue on in a controlled manner and the industries will be careful in chousing environmentally friendly technologies.
As it was stated in section 5, the uncontrolled landfill sites in Kemalpa¦a region should be improved as soon as possible and a sanitary landfill site should be formed. Of course site selection for a sanitary landfill is not something that could be done by 2 or 3 people. This kind of a decision should be given after an environmental impact report is prepare by a group of scientists. The “Solid Waste Control Regulation” in acted in 14th May 1991 in the official newspaper number 20814, gives the official measures to be taken for solid wastes in Turkey. So it is very important to take the advice of various experts in this area in order to find the best solution.
As a result of all these aspects, the most appropriate and economic solution for the solid wastes of Kemalpa¦a was found to be sanitary landfill. But in order to increase the operation period of this sanitary landfill, recycling technologies should be improved for solid wastes also they should be separated at their sources, and environmentally friendly technologies should be chosen by the industries which minimize wastes while maximize production.
REFERENCES :
Horn , A. ,1989, Zur TA Sonderabfall 1989- Anmerkungen zum Abschnitt Oberirdische Deponien. Abfallwirtschaftsjournal, Nr.12 S.40 - 43, EF Verlag Berlin.
Kruse, Thomas ,1988 , Standsicherheit der Deponieböschung. Entsorgungspraxis 7. S. 300-303, Gütersloh,
Runge, M. ,1979,”Müllsickerwasser” UBA - Forschungsbericht, Berlin
Quentmeier, V. ,198,”Behandlung von Stau- und Sickerwaessern aus Sonderabfalldeponien” Universitaet Hannover, H.72 (SBzA,1987)
Reuter , E. ,1988, “Durchlaessigkeitsverhalten von Tonen gegenüber anorganischen und organischen Saeuren” Universitaet Braunschweig, Heft 26. 6.
Drescher, J. ,1988,”Deponiedichtungen für Sonderabfalldeponien - Arbeitspapier” Müll und Abfall , H.7 , S.281-295
Holzlöhner, U. ,1988,”Das Feuchteverhalten mineralischer Schichten in der Basisabdichtung von Deponien” Müll und Abfall H.7, S. 295-
Dokumentation der SLT ,1990,”Neuzeitliche Entwicklungen und Tendenzen beim Grundwasserschutz mit Kunststoffdichtunsbahnen” Hamburg.
Lante, D. ,1991,”Deponiesicherung und Deponiesanierung” Çevre Seminerleri Dizisi Seminer ìì-Atìk Gidermede Çaºda_ Teknikler ve ÿzmir Kenti - 19-21 Mart 1991,ÿzmir
Lante, D. ,1991,”Stand der Technik bei der Errichtung von Sied- lungsabfall- und Sonderabfalldeponien “ Çevre Seminerleri Dizisi Seminer ìì-Atìk Gidermede Çaºda_ Teknikler ve ÿzmir Kenti - 19-21 Mart 1991,ÿzmir
Kollar, M.,1991,”Verfahren zur Behandlung von Sickerwasser”Çevre Seminerleri Dizisi Seminer ìì-Atìk Gidermede Çaºda_ Teknikler ve ÿzmir Kenti - 19-21 Mart 1991,ÿzmir
Lorber, K.E. ,1991,”Die Deponieschadstoffe” Çevre Seminerleri Dizisi Seminer ìì-Atìk Gidermede Çaºda_ Teknikler ve ÿzmir Kenti - 19-21 Mart 1991,ÿzmir
pen, G. ,1991,”Die Rekultivierung der Deponien” Çevre Seminer-leri Dizisi Seminer ìì-Atìk Gidermede Çaºda_ Teknikler ve ÿzmir Kenti - 19-21 Mart 1991,ÿzmir
Landesamt für Wasser und Abfall NW ,1981,”Entwurf einer Richtlinie über Depoiebasisabdichtungen aus Dichtungsbahnen” Abfallwirtschaft Nordrhein-Westfalen .Düsseldorf
Erdin, E. ,1987, “Konzeption der Krankenhauasabfalletsorgung am Beispiel der Stadt ÿZMÿR” 7. Abfallwirtschaftliches Fachkolloquium. Saarbrücken,23-24 April 1987.
Erdin, E. ,1987, “Thermische Verwertung der Abfaelle in der Türkei” THe Symposium Thermal Waste Utilization - Termiczna Utylizacja Odpadow,21-23 Mai,1987 Kozupnik, Polonya.
Erdin, E. ,1988, “ Die Abfaelle und deren Energie-Potential im Raum ÿzmir” II. Internationale Wissenschaftliche Konferenz Rationalle Anwendung von lokale Energiequellen und elektrotermischen Verbrauchern in der Landwirtschaft, 15-22 Mai, 1988, Budapest, Ungarn.
Erdin, E. ,1992, “ Arìtma Çamurunun Deponiye (Çöplüºe) ÿn_aa Edilmesi” , ÿn_aat Dünyasì Dergisi, pubat/Mart Sayìsì, ÿstanbul
Erdin, E. ,1987, “ Die Umweltvertraeglichkeitsprüfung in der Türkei-Gesetzliche Regelungen”, Umweltvertraeglichkeitsprüfung-Report 1, 23-24, Dortmund.
Neumann, U. ,1992, “ Rekultivierung von Mülldeponien” Abfallwirt-schaftsjournal 4, Nr. 01, pg 74-76, EF-Verlag Berlin.
Albers,K.H. et. al. ,1989,”Geotextilien in Deponiedichtungssystemen” Entsorgungspraxis 6. Gütersloh,
Saathoff, F. ,et.al. ,1992, “Zum Einsatz von Geotextilien im Deponiebau”,Abfallwirtschaftsjournal 4, Nr. 01, pg 15-22, EF-Verlag Berlin.
Rautenbach, R. ,1992, “Verfahren zur Nutzung von Deponiegas” Abfallwirtschaftsjournal 4, Nr. 01, pg 30-37, EF-Verlag Berlin.
Marquardt, K. ,1992, “ Sickerwasseraufbereitung” Abfallwirt-schaftsjournal 4, Nr. 01, pg 38-40, EF-Verlag Berlin.
Erdin, E. ,1992, “Solid Wastes Management and Disposal in Coastal Area of Syrian Arab Republic” Mediterranean Action Plan-United Nations Environment Programme (PAP/RAC), Split.
Erdin, E. ,1992, Çöp ve Katì Atìklar Ders ve Proje Notlarì.DEÜ, Mühendislik Mimarlìk Fakültesi. ÿZMÿR.
Erdin, E. ,1991, “ Sìzdìrmazlìk Zemininin ve Yüzeyinin Hazìrlanmasì”, ÿn_aat Dünyasì, Temmuz, Sayì 103, pg. 40-46, ÿstanbul.
WHO ,1983, “Management of waste from hospitals”, Euro Reports and Studies 97, Bergen.
Bauer, H. et al ,1991, “Standortuntersuchung für eine Abfalldeponie in einem ballungsraum .UVP 2, pg.73
Trampe,W. ,1991),” Umweltvertraeglichkeitsprüfung von Abfallrecyc-lingsanlagen” UVP 4, pg. 211
Rothhöhler,A. ,1989, “ Einbautechnologien und Verdichtungsgeraete auf Hausmülldeponien.” Entsorgungspraxis, Nr. 9. pg.412-422.
World Health Organization, ,1983,”Management of Hazardous Waste, “European Series, No. 14, Copenhagen,
Pohland, F.G. ,1975, “Accelerated Solid Waste Stabiliation and leachate Treatment by leachate Recycle Through Sanitary land fills”, Progress in Water Technology, V.7, N.3/4; G.Britian
Izmir Büyük_ehir Belediyesi (1997) : ÿzmir SWMP - Feasibility Study.
Meeting at the 13.06.1997.
Öztürk, ÿ.; O. Arìkan; A. Ba_türk and at all (1997): “ÿstanbul’da Katì Atìk Yönetimi” ÿstanbul. Unpupliced Paper.
Izmit Büyük_ehir Belediyesi (1997):”Izmit Greater Cìty Municipality Integrated Environmental Project” Izmit. 05.04.1997.
Alyanak, Ibrahim at al (1997): Bericht über Sonderabfaelle in der Westtürkei. Izmýr.